Content warning: use of prop guns, assult with a deadly weapon, racism, intimations of attempted sexual assault.
"Gun and Powder" was one of the last shows I saw in 2020 before COVID halted theater for a while. I kept an eye out, hoping it was still percolating. It's also worth noting that the original Martha Clarke I saw, passed away.
I was so excited when I saw the move to Broadway announcement, and, as we can see, booked tickets for previews. The show has evolved, more than the title. Obviously I have the misty memories of the original in my head. But I will attempt to review the current version before discussing changes.
Mary and Martha Clarke are the biracial twins of Tallulah Clarke, who is Black. She says their father ran away when he realized she was pregnant.
They grew up on a cotton plantation, that now post-slavery, they still work as sharecroppers. With some hard work and side hustles they have saved enough to buy the land. But when presented with the money, Mr. Billingsley claims he has just tripled the rent.
Fed up, the twins suggest earning money by going somewhere they can pass as white, since they can earn higher wages. Their mother gives them a gun to keep them safe. They soon discover that two young white women travelling alone are still in danger and pull the gun on their would be assaulters. One tosses his money at them and well, the idea of stripping white people, especially former slave owning white people of their money becomes their new plan.
Mary wants to make one more stop before they go home, have a little fun in a saloon. There they discover Jesse, who knows about the gun toting sisters. Only he's been waiting since the Wanted poster of Mary appealed to him. And so he offers to treat them to some finer things, clothes, jewels, fancy food. Mary loves it. Martha wants to go home.
Tensions rise from there, particularly as Martha finds herself attracted to Elijah, Jesse's Black assistant. And Jesse says things that make it clear he himself is not into interracial love.
There are kinfolk throughout acting as a sort of Greek chorus. And I do have to mention the maids Cissy and Flo who immediately recognize Mary and Martha as Black.
The songs are amazing and this cast kills them. I walked out of the theater dying to call the friend I saw "Gun and Powder" with to talk through the changes.
And so now the changes. It's hard when you see a work you saw in another version not to focus on the changes. All the changes I saw raised the stakes and also gave a few more characters agency. The themes are still there of biracial identity, and the challenge of an era where being biracial meant either passing as white or being Black, no in between.
I do think that Elijah suffered a little, because they made him a little milder, quieter, he even has a song about being invisible. But that made him seem less of an obvious match for Martha.
I do like that he dreams of California now, rather than Boston.
I also can't tell if Jesse is more obviously evil, or if it's just hard to redeem a dude who says your Wanted poster reminded him of his mom.
But these are quibbles. I still love the show. The audience I saw it with was delightfully reactive, laughing, gasping, even mm-hmming in parts.
I need a cast album of this show. I may also need a shirt that says Legend.
The prior version I saw featured Solea Pfeiffer, Awa Sal Secka, and Rayshun Lamarr, who are all part of this cast. Liisi Fontaine had been in the original workshop.