Content note: classism.
A show about teens who discover there is no budget left to put on a show, definitely feels like it has been done before. A show about teens who decide to do "Pygmalion" (public domain!) but update it for a modern audience and maybe make it a musical, has also been done before. (Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen, anyone?) But some ideas are repeated because they are great ideas. After all, I've loved approximately ten different versions of "A Christmas Carol".
I adored this show. George Bernard Washington, G.B. to his friends, as the writer/director of the show made clear how much the act of writing and directing feels a little like being Professor Higgins, trying to mold something in a new direction but discovering the thing you are trying to mold doesn't always accept your directions.
Alyzé as a broke ballerina who does subway showtime dancing to help raise funds for her schooling was wonderful.
And Colin, G.B.'s best friend who dreams of a Jimmy award, and casts a jock as Pickering to his Higgins was delightful.
The choreography was wonderful. The songs were fun. The direction was delightfully specific. If you are a person who likes peeking at the background actors, they were always doing little things that made them seem more like fully rounded characters.
My one critique would be the sound design seemed to overwhelm some of the solo singers.
And the lesson that no one wants to be Higgins, Higgins gets left all alone, community is what you need, was perfect.
(Also those of you who recall my opinion that Freddy is Liza's best choice, well, this shows agrees with me.)